UT-OH! Chapter 1: First Grade Flunkee

Unknown to me, I had grown two days older. But what did I know. I was only five years old.

I can still hear the clanking treads and feel the bite of the blade as my D-8 dug into the side of the steep hill. Dirt and rocks tumbled into the canyon below. I was working alone, cutting a logging road across mountainous terrain. A hot Indian-Summer sun was beating down on me. My body was drenched in sweat and covered in dirt. And then it happened. A portion of the cliff gave away— and the bulldozer went tumbling off the edge. 

“Fuck!” I yelled. 

It was a wonderful word, one that I had learned from my seven-year old brother, Marshall. I didn’t have a clue what it meant, but it was deliciously bad and not to be said around adults. Or my sister.

At five years of age, I was too young to be operating a bulldozer by myself in our backyard, even if it was only four-inches long and the road I was cutting was along the edge of our compost pit. But my mother wasn’t the hovering type; she drank a lot. Empty wine bottles had a way of mysteriously appearing under her bed and in the clothes’ hamper that hid out in the closet. I spent a lot of time outdoors. My mother’s alcoholism was my introduction to being alone with nature. Not necessarily a bad deal.

I wasn’t totally alone. Coaly, our black Cocker Spaniel, was assigned babysitting duty.  At “fuck!” she wagged her tail and barked into our compost pit where the toy had fallen. 

“Go get the bulldozer, girl,” I urged. She gave me a ‘go get it yourself’ look. She wasn’t the ideal faithful-dog. The gray hair around her nose and aching joints spoke to her advanced years.  She felt little need to please me and zero tolerance for my youthful pranks. Healing scars on my foot reflected how little. 

We fed Coaly and our cats canned Bonnie dog food. She got half, and each of our two cats got a quarter. She’d wolf down her food and then go after the cats’ portion. I had discovered that Coaly growled ferociously if I messed with her share. We fed our animals outside on the finest paper towels.  I always went barefoot in the summer and it was easy to reach over with my big toe and slide their food away. I quickly learned to leave the cats with their lightning fast claws alone. But Coaly was all bark and no bite. At least she was until she sunk her teeth into my foot. I ended up in the ER with a tetanus shot, stitches and zero sympathy. Coaly ended up gobbling her dinners and hassling the cats in peace.

At the time of the bulldozer incident, I had been granted a reprieve from school, or, to put it bluntly, I had been kicked out of the first grade— for a year. My mother was not happy. She had good reason to drink.

As her last child to enter school, she had been eager to get me out of the house. Make that desperate. The evidence is irrefutable. California had a rule then that five-year olds could go to the first grade if they turned six on or before March 1 of the following year. There was no such thing as kindergarten, at least in Diamond Springs in 1948. Since my birthday was on March 3, I missed the deadline by two days. Darn. 

Mother’s reaction was more colorful. She made a command decision. Forty-eight hours were not going to stand in the way of her little boy’s education, or her freedom. So, she changed my birth certificate.  March 3 was carefully erased with a typewriter eraser and March 1 typed in. I was bathed, dressed and shipped out, not the least bit aware that I had matured by two days. I think I recall hearing music and dancing in the house as my 12 year old sister walked me to school, a block away.

Things weren’t so rosy at school. The other kids were all older, bigger, and more coordinated. For example, Alan Green could draw a great horse. It came with four legs, a tail, a head and a flowing mane. Mine came with unrecognizable squiggles. It was hard to tell whether my objective was to draw a tarantula or a snake with legs, but the world’s wildest imagination on the world’s most potent drug wouldn’t have classified the picture as a horse. It was not refrigerator art. The whole exercise created big-time trauma.

This negative experience was compounded by the exercise of learning to print within lines. Forget that. If my letter came anywhere close to resembling a letter, any letter, I was happy. Mrs. Young, the teacher, was more critical.

“Curtis, I asked you to make Bs, and here you are printing Zs.”

“So what’s your point?” was not an acceptable response. Mrs. Young was suspicious and that suspicion increased each day I was in school. She was a tough old gal who had been teaching first grade for eons. She knew first graders, and I wasn’t one. As for the birth certificate, Mother’s forgery was in no danger of winning a blue ribbon at the county fair. After a few weeks, Mrs. Young sent off to Oregon for a copy. I remember her calling me up to her desk.

“Curtis” she explained, “you have a choice. You can either go home now or you can go home after school. But either way, you are going home and can’t come back until next year.” 

Just like that, I was a reject, a first grade flunkee. 

Mrs. Young couldn’t have made it any clearer: Mother was going to get her little boomerang back. This was okay by me, if not by her. Playing out in the backyard was infinitely more fun than competing in ‘Scribble the Horse.’ I did decide to stay for the day. Mrs. Young was reading about Goldilocks to us after lunch and I wanted to learn if the bears ate her.

It would have been interesting to listen in on the conversation that took place between Mother and Mrs. Young, or even more so between my mother and father, or Pop, as he was known to us. I’ve often wondered if he participated in the forgery or even knew about the March 1 rule. I doubt it. He was not the parent frantic to get me out of the house during the day.  (Had it been in the evening the jury might still be out, he laughingly reported to me years later.) But I wasn’t privy to those high-level discussions. My job, which I took quite seriously, was to enjoy the reprieve. I was about to begin my wandering ways. The Graveyard was waiting. Join me next Thursday as I learn how it served as a great playground during the day but became terrifying at night when the ghosts slithered out from their graves.

The change that made me two days older. I don’t know if this was the evidence that led to my being booted out of the first grade but the change is obvious. First, check out the the size of the ‘1′ in March 1 with the ‘1′ in 1943. While the type face is the same, the first 1 is much smaller. Second, but less obvious, there is a slight indentation and discoloration of the certificate where my mother used the typewriter eraser.

19 thoughts on “UT-OH! Chapter 1: First Grade Flunkee

  1. Funny story. Under your California rules, I wouldn’t have made it into first grade, either. But in Iowa at the time, I was eligible for kindergarten at the ripe old age of four (October something or other was the cutoff), so I also entered first grade before I turned five. I think it might have been more of a problem socially than anyone realized at the time, but since I’d been reading the newspaper with my dad at age three, I was more than ready for reading and writing. (I did have trouble with sharing; a result of life as an only child, probably.)

    • You were lucky to have the early preparation your parents gave you, Linda. Obviously it made a significant difference. Being bright didn’t hurt eiither. The social piece is harder to quantify. In retrospect, being older helped me in a number of ways regarding my relationships with other kids.

    • Ut-Oh, you caught me Steve. Not really but I did get in one fight in first grade. And got spanked for it. But that’s a story to come. There were definitely advantages to being slightly older than the other kids, however.

  2. Oh I loved this story which I read and could read and re-read, Curt.. It’s a wonder you came out with the gumption and smarts you have and FUCK you learned how to tell a story. I’m sending this to my 2 girls with babies when they think they have it bad.. lol
    You not only went unscathed, you added to those cuts and bruises with tough skin with a rich life.
    Indeed this is so true and hysterical..
    “My mother was not happy. She had good reason to drink”.
    I still can’t get over how she changed your birth certificate. You gotta love her.. haha.
    xo

  3. I can actually see the wisdom of age limits, especially in early grades! My youngest was technically old enough to go to kindergarten, but physically and emotionally maybe not old enough. She did fine, but I could see a year later how entering Grade 1 was going to be not so good for her. Fortunately we moved, so I put her back into Kindergarten in the new school district! That made the transition a year later into Grade 1 easy… until she finished that Grade and announced she could now print and read and saw no reason to continue going to school…

    • Laughing about ‘no reason to continue going to school.’ Precocious! You certainly showed wisdom in running her through Kindergarten twice. I have forever been glad that Mrs. Young insisted I needed another year. I believe it made a significant difference in my life for the better.

  4. Curt, I’m impressed with your mother’s inventiveness and the lengths she went to get you into school a year early! I smiled that you decided to stay for the day – to listen to the end of the story. The best of reasons! Were they still drawing horses when you returned a year later?

    • My mother had a creative mind, no doubt about it Annika! Especially when it came into getting into mischief. Something that I inherited, I’m afraid. I’ve always loved a good story. As for horses I don’t remember. I do have a photo of a finger painting, however. Given all of the squiggly lines, I’d probably get away with declaring it modern art today.

    • Laughing. I’m sure that you will see more. There are lots of reasons in the stories I am going to tell.
      Brilliant but devious, I might add. I’m glad it backfired. I still might be in the first grade.

  5. So much in the story, I loved it! Oh you know, at the very time you were just learning to use the grown up word, my country was getting closer to regaining her independence!

    “So what’s your point?” was hilarious! And your mother sounds like an interesting woman, what all did she do with her time? Would love to know more about her, especially since you say you got her mischevious DNA 😄

    • Thanks. 😁 It seems long, long ago, and yet not so long. Incredible changes in the world, since.
      My mother was primarily an at home mom at the time, as most women in the US were. She did work in real estate. Her dream was becoming a writer.

  6. I knewwwww I’d have at least one thing in common, writing it is!

    I could feel her so well. Just that right now I don’t have three kids to chase away and I can’t digest alcohol, but I totally get the vibe of listening to good music, getting drunk at home solo, and basically just enjoying her own company. I could do that! Absolutely would!

    Will be awesome if you share more about her in your Ut-Oh! Memoirs!

Leave a comment